JURY CONVICTS GUARD OF KILLING HARLEM MAN IN UPSTATE NY PRISON, JURORS SPEAK
JONAH LEVY CONVICTED OF MANSLAUGHTER AND RELATED CHARGES IN 2025 KILLING OF MESSIAH NANTWI
Former New York State prison guard Jonah Levy being handcuffed by court officers after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter and related crimes for beating inmate Messiah Nantwi to death inside the Mid-State Correctional Facility on Mar. 1, 2026. Photo credit: JB Nicholas.
UTICA, NEW YORK Apr. 1, 2026 Last updated: 10:59 PM
A former state prison guard was led crying from an upstate New York courtroom after a jury convicted him of manslaughter and related crimes for "curb stomping" a black prisoner to death in 2025.
Jonah Levy did not look back at family members as presiding judge Michael R. Nolan revoked his bail, as court officers handcuffed him and as they led Levy from the courtroom to a cell in the Oneida County jail.
Levy's supporters, sitting on a bench behind him in State Supreme Court, burst into tears when the jury of 10 men and two women announced their verdict shortly after noon on Wednesday.
The only bright spot for Levy was the jury's decision to spare him a murder conviction. The 39-year-old faces a maximum sentence of 25 years in prison. Had he been convicted of murder, he would have faced a life sentence.
The jury also convicted Levy of gang assault in the first and second degrees, conspiracy and offering a false instrument for filing by submitting a fake official report denying he beat the prisoner, 22-year-old Harlem man Messiah Nantwi.
The jury’s verdict came on the eighth day of Levy's trial, which started Mar. 23. The jury was given the case to decide by judge Nolan on Monday.
“He never should have been a CO. He was a bad man,” William J. Fitzpatrick, the Onondaga County District Attorney who was appointed Special Prosecutor in the case, told The Free Lance News after Wednesday’s verdict.
Levy was on probation for beating another prisoner in 2023.
Former New York State prison guard Jonah Levy being led to jail by court officers after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter and related crimes for beating inmate Messiah Nantwi to death inside the Mid-State Correctional Facility on Mar. 1, 2025. Photo credit: JB Nicholas.
Dominick Wofford, 20, was the only black person on the jury. He spoke to The Free Lance News outside the State Supreme Court courthouse in Utica where Levy was tried.
Wofford said he thought the evidence presented by prosecutors justified a murder conviction. But Wofford said his fellow jurors thought it only justified a first degree manslaughter conviction.
“I was pretty strong on murder for a while. I wanted to see the murder charge get done,” Wofford said. But, he added, “a lot of my fellow jurors wanted just, only manslaughter."
“Even if he wasn’t the one who directly killed him,” Wofford explained his conclusion about Levy, “I know he was in that room watching what was going on and didn’t really make an attempt to stop anything so I definitely wanted to find him guilty.”
Adrian Stinger was one of the jurors who thought the facts only justified a manslaughter conviction.
"I’ll take full blame,” Stinger told the Free Lance News by telephone Wednesday evening. “There was a group of us. Maybe evenly split.”
When it came to the manslaughter, gang assault, conspiracy and false report charges, there was never any question of Levy’s guilt of those charges in the jury’s mind.
"Everything else we got him dead to rights,” Stinger said.
The only debate was whether to convict Levy of murder in addition to all the other charges.
“Eight hours of that was going back and forth over the murder,” Stinger revealed.
The remainder of the jurors declined to comment.
Nantwi's killing took place less than three months after another "beat-up squad" of all white guards killed Robert Brooks at the Marcy Correctional Facility on Dec. 9, 2024. Marcy is directly across the road from the Mid-State Correctional Facility, where Nantwi was killed on Mar. 1, 2025.
Fitzpatrick was the Special Prosecutor in the Brooks’ case too. He referred to the murder, manslaughter and other convictions he secured in that case in a news conference in a courthouse hallway after Levy’s conviction on Wednesday.
“Its really despicable, isn’t it?,” Fitzpatrick told reporters. “10 days after a group of people at Marcy are indicted for murder and other charges you have a homicide committed 500 yards away.”
Family and friends of Jonah Levy react to the jury’s verdict finding him guilty of manslaughter and related crimes for killing Messiah Nantwi. Photo credit: JB Nicholas.
Levy was the first guard to go to trial for killing Nantwi. A total of 10 guards have pleaded guilty to charges related to his killing. Four chose trials, including Levi. Caleb Blair and Craig Klemick are scheduled to go to trial May 4. Thomas Eck is scheduled to go to trial June 1.
Nantwi, then 22, was beaten with fists, batons and boots in at least two different locations inside Mid-State, evidence presented by prosecutors at Levy's trial showed. Guards beat Nantwi so sadistically they left a boot-print on his forehead.
Levy and the guards who beat Nantwi belonged to a prison version of a police SWAT team called a "Corrections Emergency Response Team." CERT for short. Levy was charged with "acting in concert" with other members of the CERT team to kill Nantwi.
Nathan Palmer, a former member of Mid-State's CERT team, testified for the prosecution against Levy.
"I saw Officer Levi kick the individual in the head three to six times, curb-stomped him,” Palmer testified.
Michael Moon, Nantwi's roommate at Mid-State, testified a guard matching Levy’s description kicked Nantwi so hard “His face bounced off the locker.” The blow knocked Nantwi out, but Levy didn’t stop. He “stomped on his face.”
Then, Moon testified, the CERT team “took out their batons” and "continuously started beating on him."
Guards at Mid-State were issued body cameras and were required to activate their body cameras when using force against prisoners, according to official policy put into effect after Brooks' murder by guards at Marcy. Most Mid-State guards ignored the new policy.
Only one of the sergeants leading the CERT team the day Nantwi was killed, Sgt. Michael Iffert, was wearing a body camera and activated it to record. When Levy allegedly stomped on Nantwi's head, Iffert's body camera was facing down a hallway instead of into the room where it was happening, the video and testimony at Levy's trial showed.
But Sgt. Iffert's body camera did capture sound.
A loud metallic bang can be heard on the audio of the video captured by Sgt. Iffert’s body worn camera. The sound aligned with the testimony that’s when Levy kicked Nantwi in the face and his head ricocheted off his metal locker.
Following the loud metallic bang, close to two dozen dull slaps can be heard for almost a minute.
“That’s their batons hitting him,” Moon testified.
Wofford, the juror, considered Levy’s failure to use a body cameras when he was supposed to as evidence of his guilt.
"I really thought it was suspicious,” Wofford revealed. “All six of them not having body cameras?"
Stinger, the other juror, said the lack of body camera video did make the jury’s job more difficult. But, in the end, "you don't know exactly what happened, but you knew it went too far."
Jonah Levy fist-bumping with a fellow New York State prison guards after allegedly “curb-stomping” Messiah Nantwi to death at the Mid-State Correctional Facility outside Utica Mar. 1, 2025. Photo credit: Body-worn camera video from the New York State Department of Correctional Services and Community Supervision.
After the beating, Levy and Blair carried Nantwi to the prison's infirmary where they placed him in a holding cell. After placing Nantwi in the cell, Levy and Blair fist-bumped, body camera video from inside the infirmary captured by former Correction Officer Adam Joseph showed.
As Nantwi was being killed, a sergeant responsible for supervising Nantwi's killers explained Mid-State's usual way of dealing with alleged troublemakers—like Nantwi—to a new co-worker.
"You fuck up, you fucking got beat. Period. Period," the Corrections Sergeant bragged to a National Guard soldier in a leaked body camera recording exclusively obtained by The Free Lance News. "It was the fucking wild, wild west here."
Joseph, another former Correction Officer who testified for the prosecution, saw that Levy, Blair and the CERT team were about to beat Nantwi again inside Mid-State’s infirmary. This time in the holding cell, right in front of Joseph’s body camera, which was still recording.
Joseph picked up his camera and put it on a ledge just inside an adjacent bathroom. The camera was pointed toward a toilet in the back of the bathroom, but was close enough to the entrance to capture guards speaking outside.
"If you try anything stupid, its going to be the last move you ever fucking make," Sgt. Francis Chandler told Nantwi, according to Joseph and audio his body-camera captured.
Sgt. Chandler also helped lead Mid-State's CERT team. Chandler pleaded guilty to gang assault in January. He faces up to four years in prison when he is sentenced later this year.
While Joseph's body camera did not capture video of it, Joseph testified he saw the CERT team beating Nantwi again.
"I saw movement, like he was getting hit," Joseph said.
The Special Prosecutor’s winning team, left to right, William J. Fitzpatrick, Onondaga County District Attorney; (c, seated) Sara M. Fitzpatrick, Senior Assistant Onondaga County District Attorney; and (r, standing) Alphonse L. Williams, also an Assistant Onondaga County District Attorney. Photo credit: JB NIcholas.
After Nantwi was beaten again by the CERT team, Sgts. David Ferrone and Ryan Russell entered the bathroom where Joseph's body-camera was still recording. They didn't see the camera until it was too late.
"Where's that weapon from before?," one of them asked.
“Oh fuck,” one said moments later when they realized they’d been recorded.
Though they spotted the camera and realized it caught them conspiring, they went ahead anyway and orchestrated the filing of paperwork falsely alleging guards recovered a shank from Nantwi's cell. They used a shank that had been given to them by National Guard soldiers earlier in the day to do it.
The shank they turned in and claimed to be Nantwi's did not have Nantwi's DNA on it, State Police Forensic Scientist Kristine Robinson testified last Thursday.
Ferrone pleaded guilty to tampering with physical evidence. He was sentenced to a one year conditional discharge.
While Russell and Ferrone were plotting to cover-up Nantwi's beating, Nantwi went into cardiac arrest.
"Fuck! He ain't moving," according to the audio. "You fucked him up."
Police seized Levy's boots three days after the killing, testimony by a State Police investigator established. Nantwi's blood was on both of Levy's boots, state police forensic scientists testified.
Graeme Spicer, Levy’s defense lawyer, argued to the jury there was a "pretty reasonable explanation for how blood got on his boots." Levy, simply, “coulda stepped in [Nantwi’s] blood."
But the jury wasn’t convinced.
"I thought it was a weak defense," Wofford, one of the jurors, said.
Referring to a prison nurse Spicer called to testify in Levy's defense, who claimed Nantwi gave him the finger while handcuffed behind his back after he was carried dying into the infirmary, "I thought Mr. Savitsky was pretty unreliable."
Stinger, the other juror who spoke, said he felt good about convicting Levy.
"America wins,” he said. “There's justice for Mr. Nantwi and Levy doesn't get out until he’s old enough to qualify for social security."
Judge Nolan scheduled Levy’s sentencing for May 27.
Send tips or corrections to jasonbnicholas@gmail.com or, if you prefer, thefreelancenews@proton.me