GANG OF ALL-WHITE GUARDS WHO KILLED BROOKS AT UPSTATE NEW YORK PRISON IN 2024 CALLED HIM A RACIAL EPITHET WHILE THEY TORTURED AND KILLED HIM, REGULARLY USED RACIST LANGUAGE
MALONE, NEW YORK Nov. 16, 2026
Newly-disclosed evidence suggests the murder of a black inmate by a beat-up squad of guards in an upstate New York prison was a racist hate crime, The Free Lance News reveals.
Robert Brooks told his killers he wasn't a "nigger" or a "slave" minutes before the all-white squad attacked and killed him—arguably to teach him a lesson that he was.
During the murder, at least one of Brooks' killers called him a "boon"—an obscure but historical racial epithet derived from baboon.
Guards at Marcy used "boon" and other racist language regularly.
Although 11 white guards were successfully prosecuted for killing Brooks, failing to stop it or trying to cover it up, and 9 of them received a combined total of 96 years in prison, the fact Brooks' murder was motivated at least in part by racial hatred was not made public—until now.
Recovered body-camera video unintentionally recorded by Brooks' killers themselves showed the all-white squad laughing and joking as they punched, kicked and choked the 43-year-old Brooks to death inside the infirmary at the Marcy Correctional Facility outside Utica in 2024.
But the video lacked sound so the public never knew what Brooks' killers said—to Brooks or each other—during the murder. The video was silent because it was passively recorded.
Guards at Marcy were first issued body-cameras months before they killed Brooks, but high-ranking state prison officials let them get away with not turning them on when they used force, The Free Lance News first-reported last March. Unknown to the guards, the cameras were secretly set to record video without sound as long as they were powered on.
That's how the video exposing Brooks' murder was captured.
Brooks was transferred to Marcy for his protection Dec. 9. He was attacked by prisoners at the Mohawk Correctional Facility twice in three days before that, testimony at the trials of his killers showed. When Brooks arrived at Marcy, a guard there made a provocative announcement over the hand-held radios guards carry, according to two Marcy officers who spoke to police investigating Brooks' killing.
"You're not going to like this one coming in," Sgt. Michael Mashaw said he heard, according to a recording of his police interview obtained by The Free Lance News.
Former Marcy guard Shea E. Schoff remembered that radio transmission, but said he heard it a little differently.
"They called on the radio to 'couple guys come up-front, and wait 'til you get a load of this guy,'" Schoff told investigators, a recording of his police interview obtained by The Free Lance News shows.
"That woulda been the start of the situation," Schoff said.
Guards Nicholas Kieffer, Nicholas Anzalone and Robert Kessler went to Marcy's administration building to escort Brooks to the prison's infirmary—where new arrivals are taken to be screened when they arrive late in the evening, like Brooks did. Meanwhile, Sgt. Mashaw, Sgt. Glenn Trombly and CO Anthony Farina waited in a van outside the infirmary.
It was Sgt. Trombly's job to interview Brooks about potential security threats. He planned to do that after a nurse screened the already-injured Brooks for health issues at the infirmary, Trombly told police, according to a recording of that interview The Free Lance News obtained.
Sgt. Trombly suspected a secret plot by Farina and Kieffer to teach the "trouble-making" Brooks a lesson by giving him a "Marcy welcome" because "Kieffer can be like that," the recording shows.
Kieffer belonged to the prison's gang intelligence squad, the Crisis Intervention Unit, or CIU. Farina led the CIU. Anzalone and Kessler were members of Marcy's Corrections Emergency Response Team. CERT teams are the prison version of police SWAT teams.
Farina wasn't part of Marcy's CERT team, but the two special units—CIU and CERT—worked together to maintain order with vigilante force at Marcy.
"If the system won't keep them in line, we will," Kessler told police investigating Brooks murder, according to a recording of his interview with police, also obtained by The Free Lance News.
"What we're been doing for years has finally caught up to us," Kessler confessed.
Instead of admitting Brooks to Marcy the usual way, though a double-gated portal in the fence that surrounds it called a "truck-trap," guards admitted Brooks through the administration building. That meant Brooks had to carry his property from the transport van into the prison fully-shackled: handcuffs, leg irons, a waist chain and the so-called "black box"—which covers the handcuffs and secures them to the chain with a padlock.
Brooks had two bags' worth of personal property. Fully-shackled, Brooks carried at least one of his bags from the van into the building's lobby, then refused to carry it any further, police interviews of Kessler, Kieffer and Steven M. Caufield, one of the two Mohawk guards who transported Brooks to Marcy, show.
"I'm not a nigger. I'm not carrying my own property. I'm not a slave," Brooks said at some point, Kieffer told investigators.
Guards left Brooks' bags in Marcy's lobby and walked Brooks through a double-gated entrance into the secure area of the prison. Once inside, Caufield unshackled Brooks. Kessler said he told Brooks to put his hands in his pockets "because that's what we do when they're walking."
Brooks, Kessler claimed, didn't put his hands in his pockets deep enough.
Kessler claimed he was in the middle of repeating his order when guard Christopher Walrath "comes from the right of me and just crushes the dude into the wall." Walrath put Brooks in a "choke-hold," Kessler said, "like front head-lock from UFC and is yanking up on him."
Walrath was assigned to work the arsenal that night, a secured area of prison akin to a large safe or vault where weapons are stored. Its inside Marcy’s administration building next to the entrance Brooks’ passed through, evidence at the trials of Brooks' killers showed. The only people Walrath’s job in the arsenal required him to interact with were other guards, dropping off and drawing weapons.
Walrath went out of his way and left his assigned post to attack Brooks.
Kessler, Anzalone and Kieffer joined Walrath and hit Brooks too.
Brooks didn't fight back, Caufield, the guard from Mohawk, told police, a recording of his interview shows.
"For some reason," Caufield added, "those officers just waxed out on him."
A moment passed before Walrath let go of Brooks. Blood was on the wall where Brooks' face was.
The last time Caufield saw Brooks, Kessler and Anzalone each had their hands on Brooks and were leading him through a door into the prison compound.
Once outside in the open-air, Kieffer ordered Kessler and Anzalone to put Brooks on the ground, Kieffer and Kessler said. Then Kieffer peppersprayed Brooks in the face, according to both Kieffer's and Kessler's police interviews.
Trombly told police he thought Kieffer did it to cover-up the assault inside the administration building.
Nothing up to this point was captured on the body-camera video that's been made public. It's only from this point forward that body-camera video was recovered, according to police testimony at the trials of Brooks' killers.
That video shows a handcuffed Brooks frog-marched by Anzalone and Kessler toward the infirmary. Another guard, David J. Kingsley III, follows behind. Kingsley picks up Brooks's feet at some point because body-camera video captured the trio carrying Brooks into the infirmary moments later.
They carry Brooks into what workers call the "emergency room" and place him on a treatment table. Still handcuffed behind his back, Anzalone, Farina, Kessler, Walrath and Kingsley beat, kick and choke Brooks to death.
Sgts. Trombly and Mashaw, inside the room, watched the murder taking place in front of them and did not stop it.
CO Mathew J. Galliher pushed Brooks down onto the table during the attack and held him there. CO David Walters ordered nurses to stay out of the room while guards killed Brooks. CO Michael Fisher stood in the doorway and gawked. CO Schoff laughed with guards in the same hallway.
"In the room everybody's going nuts," Sgt. Trombly told police. "They're all, like, hitting the guy," Trombly said.
"Somewheres in there I hear somebody call him a 'stupid boon,'" Trombly recalled, "Like, 'why you got to be racist?'"
Later in the same interrogation, Trombly told police again "I heard 'stupid boon' or something."
Trombly explained guards at Marcy considered "boon" a racial epithet and used it along with "spook" and "nigger."
Prof. Rodney Coates, who teaches Critical Race Theory in the Department of Global and Intercultural Studies at Miami University in Ohio, confirmed "boon" is indeed a racial epithet.
"The more complete term," Prof. Coates explained, is "baboon. That's where 'boon' comes from."
The black American slang term for close companion, "ace boon coon," is also an example.
It wasn't surprising, Prof. Coates explained, that racist law enforcement officers would use an unconventional or vague racial epithet like "boon" because "if you're overheard, you could deny it. You got plausible deniability."
"With these kinds of terms," Coates said, "sometimes you want to use a term they might not understand."
Kieffer told police he heard all the guards connected to Brooks' murder say "nigger" at work except Galliher and Fisher. (He claimed Kessler also did not use racial epithets, but Trombly said Kessler did too and Kessler himself admitted “bigotry.)
Anzalone, Kieffer agreed, "stands out as particularly mouthy in that regard."
Anzalone regularly called black prisoners he beat the N-word, both during the abuse and bragging about it later, Kieffer said.
Kieffer admitted he himself used the N-word at work when he gets angry
"Very small things like that," he claimed.
Schoff told police "the N-word gets thrown around." That's "the word that gets used the most."
Sgt. Mashaw said his colleagues used the N-word "daily."
"I hear nigger all the time," he said.
"If I really get pissed off," he admitted, "I've said 'stupid nigger' once in a while."
Mashaw admitted the last time he got that mad was a few months ago.
Walters also said guards used racial epithets "daily." But Walrath and Farina, he agreed, spoke it more than others.
"Those are the two," Walters told police, "I've heard say multiple times."
Kessler, for his part, said "Gotta be, bear a level of bigotry toward them, towards the inmates, the same way they do to us."
Not all the guards allegedly involved in Brooks murder were convicted. Kieffer and Galliher were acquitted at the same trial that sent Kinglsey to prison for 25-years-to-life. Farina and Anzalone got 22 years, each. Walrath got 15. Mashaw got 3-to-9. Walters 2 1/3-to-7. Kessler 4 years. Trombly got back-to-back bullets in the Oneida County jail. Fisher got six months. Schoff got one-year conditional discharge and a fine.
Less than three months after Brooks was murdered by the beat-up squad at Marcy, another black New Yorker, Messiah Nantwi, was murdered by another all-white beat-up squad at the Mid-State Correctional Facility on Mar. 1, 2025.
Mid-State is literally across the road from Marcy.
State Attorney General Letitia James and Gov. Kathy Hochul's hand-picked state prison chief, Daniel F. Martuscello III, were explicitly warned about Marcy's beat-up squad at least as early as 2023, 13 months before the squad killed Brooks, The Free Lance News first-reported Dec. 26, 2024.
New York just paid $650,000 to settle the federal civil rights lawsuit that gave them that warning last Monday, The Free Lance News also first-reported.
“Commissioner Martuscello and DOCCS will not tolerate any verbal or physical acts of racial bias,” Thomas Mailey, Deputy Commissioner of Public Information for the state Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, said in an emailed statement. “We will hold perpetrators fully accountable for these actions and will refer cases for internal discipline and when applicable for criminal prosecution.”
“In the case of the murder of Robert Brooks,” Mailey added, “the Department fully cooperated with the Special Counsel and was responsible for the discovery of and turning over the passive body worn camera footage that was key evidence in the case.”
Send tips or corrections to jasonbnicholas@gmail.com or, if you prefer, thefreelancenews@proton.me